Weight Lifting & Open Posture Part 1
Hey you,
I’ve been wanting to write about how I’ve grown to think about weight lifting and open posture for a few reasons:
One, we’ve been brainwashed to believe that THE only way to remineralize bone and grow muscle is through heavy lifting, which simply isn’t true.
Two, you guys, like me once upon a time (last year lol), are always asking me how to fit this work into your weight lifting program.
Three, when you guys do the “bow inspired” weight lifting challenges done by others on social media, you get hurt and ask me about why & how to heal by the hundreds.
Let me help.
This became extraordinarily long, so this will be a two part newsletter and eventually an entire month’s theme in REVIVAL.
Let’s start with the first point. There are a couple main levers you can pull if you’re looking to grow muscle and increase/protect your bone density. But first you have to understand that your bones are literally regrowing every moment depending on the load the muscles are putting on them. I’m talking like you can change not only the shape and density of your bones but also how your joints fit together with your muscles – it’s wild.
We have usually only been taught about one lever, heavy loading. Which of course can build muscle, but also strengthens you into your compensations to accomplish the goal and won’t leave you with a supple, happy body unless you’re a gifted, freak of nature.
The other levers for building your tissues are speed and self generated resistance. Speed is why jumping classically remineralizes bone - you’re putting high load into your tissues over a shorter period of time. Your body responds by making you stronger to take that load.
The often forgotten lever is self generated load. Your body doesn’t actually care what number is on the bumbell, it responds to how much load it feels. This is where Bowspring shines.
In this work, we are learning how to contract our muscles against each other (but long contraction, not making the muscles shorter which is why I like to call it toning because contraction makes us think shortness). This means that your bicep feels like you’re lifting something heavy and so does your tricep, at the same time. Said another way, you can put 100 pounds on your glutes (usually actually loading most of that onto quads or hip capsule because of our traditional alignment) or you can create 100 pounds of resistance with your hamstrings and glutes engaging against your quads and hip flexors.
It’s like you are your own weights.
But this isn’t an easy thing to feel, let alone teach. So like so much of traditional medicine, we’ve just made a blanket statement to everyone that lifting heavier is the only way to be healthy, losing the nuance of reality.
I woke up this morning with the sorest triceps of my life. This isn’t because I've never tried loading them in the gym. This is because I never had the alignment of my bones to actually get the load on them. My other parts just compensated.
We all know this experience – the person who lifts heavy but still has small legs, the woman with osteoporosis who lifts but still doesn’t get meaningfully denser bones or the many exercises tried to grow glutes that just won’t listen. It’s neither because the exercise chosen is inherently wrong, nor is it solely how heavy you do it that brings changes to the body, it is how you are doing it. And you can imagine why that complicates things.
It needs to be said that if you don’t have enough minerals or protein, no amount of anything will grow muscle because you don’t have the building blocks for it. I say this because there’s many women who are casually restricting their intake of nutrients but see it as normal. You have to eat a lot of meat and minerals to thrive.
To my second point above, this stuff can’t fit on top of your weight lifting plan. I know it’s sad. I fought against it for months (my husband fought it for years) and thought I could create a way to lift and still open myself. I truly loved to lift.
But here’s the truth. Your body cannot and will not change the way you are moving and also be able to lift something heavy (even 5 pounds). As soon as you load yourself, your body goes back into the way that it knows it can accomplish the task, simple as that.
What this doesn’t mean is that weight lifting is bad, or that you can’t do it forever. And your goals should change what you do. If you want a power lifter’s body where you have super big, super short muscles, and you’re willing to have joint pain – this advice doesn’t work for you! But if you want to be long and lean, more like how all nourished animals look, with amazing feeling joints long past 50 years old – I'm talking to you.
Set the weight down and realize how insanely hard focusing on form over load is, and watch your body transform.
I’ve named this focus on form ‘progressive form overload’. As many of you know, the traditional principle in strength training that we use to build ourselves up is called progressive overload. It’s simply where you have to continually increase the weight to continue to make changes. This is true. But not the only way.
How I think about my workouts now is with progressive overload of form cues, not weight. Each time I workout, I push myself to a high (8-9, 0 being none, 10 being the hardest thing imaginable) "rate of perceived exertion” or RPE through more nuanced alignment and more tone on each side of my joint.
This isn’t simple to write out or do at first, so if you’re curious i’d enroll in REVIVAL and start the foundation series (you won’t be able to even tone this hard for a while, you have to earn the alignment first). It is the hardest thing I’ve ever done in my life and it has caused me to look and feel truly better than I ever thought was possible.
As I wrote this newsletter it hit me that this needs to be the next theme in REVIVAL. There is just so much to say so you understand what we’ve spent our entire professional careers figuring out.
Respond to this email with your favorite name for this theme:
Strength From Within
Build Without Weights
Bodyweight, Built Different
Strong Without Heavy
The No-Weights Strength Month
& what questions you have about this theme.
Keep your eyes peeled for part 2 next week where I get more into the nuance of how to shift your workouts, your diet and not get hurt in the process.
All my love,
Dr. Lily